John Chayka's Maple Leafs are 8-12-2 after a sixth straight loss, and the rebuild debate in Toronto is getting louder.

The latest defeat came Saturday night, 1-0 to Edmonton. The Leafs are 2-8-0 over their last 10 and head to Chicago on Tuesday. Plenty of fans wanted the teardown to start the day Chayka arrived to take over a team that had finished 28th.

Some people believe Chayka talked ownership out of a rebuild to get the job. That's nonsense.

The Leafs don't own their first-round picks for the next two seasons, and those happen to be the last two seasons Auston Matthews is under contract. So the thinking was simple: see where Matthews stands, and if he's in, take a run at being competitive under strict conditions.

Condition one: nothing done for the present can get in the way of the future beyond Matthews. Condition two: the 2029 first-round pick is untouchable, because that's the first draft after his deal expires and the point where a rebuild could realistically begin.

The summer looked like a front office sticking to that script. Toronto made 10 picks in the 2026 draft and signed free agents to short-term deals of two and three years. It also cut bait on players who hadn't lived up to expectations in Toronto, with Joseph Woll and Brandon Carlo among them.

The prospect pool got better right away, and the club locked up Darren Raddysh and Kirill Marchenko long term. By consensus, the roster improved on paper.

The results haven't followed. After 22 games, Sergei Bobrovsky's rough start in Toronto looks like a bet that went wrong.

The Matthews window gives Toronto time before any teardown

The Leafs needed impact defensemen and they knew it. They were in on Zachary Werenski, but they couldn't get it done without breaking their own conditions.

What they have instead is four underperforming defensemen between 32 and 36 years old, all with term on their contracts and trade protection. That makes life hard for the GM trying to make a deal, and it makes life hard for the team on the ice.

So why not tear it down now? There's nothing to sell it for, because the picks aren't theirs. Matthews has 12 goals and 29 points in 22 games, and a talent like that is a swing you take every time. If he decides he wants out, there's plenty of time to move him, whether that's March or next summer.

Everybody is measuring this team against expectations built on the idea that it was better than last year or that the summer fixed enough. Nobody is measuring it against last year's 28th-place finish, because nobody wants to admit the Matthews era might be over.

Firing Jim Hiller looks unlikely, since there's little precedent for dismissing a coach this early, especially one who inherited the 28th-place club. John Chayka's Monday press conference on Jim Hiller pointed the same way: Chayka is standing behind his coach and still looking to add a defenseman, according to David Pagnotta.

We doubt the front office knew what to expect from this group after last season. It looks more like a best effort and a hypothesis than a sure playoff team. If management really believed in a playoff run, it was careful not to say so, and that would have put more pressure on Hiller. More likely it blames the awful start on roster construction.

We hoped the Leafs would be better, and we still expect them to climb above where they sit today. Playoffs are a stretch. Most of the damage was done before the new players got here, and the emergency repair never came together.

It was never this or a rebuild, though. There's always been a contingency, and the Leafs have acted accordingly. If they deviate from it, that's when the concern starts, and Matthews' spring decision still hangs over all of it.

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence, based on public reports and official sources.

POLL
14 HOURS AGO |158 ANSWERS
John Chayka's pitch to Maple Leafs ownership: what happened behind closed doors

What is the right call for the Maple Leafs from here?

Also read on Markerzone.com:
Report: Canucks want to hand Elias Pettersson a major responsibility instead of trading him