Senators trading Brady Tkachuk? Friedman outlines the only scenario

PUBLICATION

David St-Jean
May 4, 2026  (5:19)

SHARE THIS STORY

Photo credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

Elliotte Friedman dropped a line on 32 Thoughts that should cool every Brady Tkachuk trade rumour humming around Ottawa this week.

Speaking on the April 29 episode, Friedman said the Senators are not entertaining a Tkachuk trade unless one gets jammed down their throat.

His exact framing: it's not going to be their choice, ever, and any move would have to be forced upon them.

That's a hard line from a guy who rarely speaks in absolutes. And it lands days after Ottawa's season ended in the first round.

The Senators were swept 4-0 by Carolina, capped by a 2-4 home loss on April 25 that closed a year built around the captain's leadership.

Tkachuk finished the playoffs without a point in four games and went minus-4. The numbers don't lie, and they don't flatter him either.

Travis Green's group still finished 44-27-11 with 99 points and a +32 goal differential. That's a real team, not a rebuild needing a teardown.

Staios isn't burning that down to chase a hypothetical return. Tkachuk's $8,205,714 cap hit through his prime years is exactly the kind of contract contenders crave, which is the entire problem.

The regular season told a different story than the postseason. Tkachuk put up 22 goals and 37 assists in 60 games, with 5 power play markers and a shorthanded goal mixed in.

A captain who plays heavy minutes, kills penalties, and drags his line into the dirty areas of the ice doesn't get replaced through a trade portal. You replace a guy like that the way you replace a load-bearing wall. You don't.

Still, the noise won't stop. Cap-strapped contenders will keep calling. Agents will keep listening. And Friedman's wording leaves a sliver of daylight.

Forced upon them. What does that even look like in practice? A trade request? A contract standoff? Something neither side has hinted at publicly?

For now, the front office is signalling a clear answer to the rest of the league. Make an offer Ottawa cannot refuse, or stop dialling.

The eye test from those four Carolina games will hang over the summer regardless. Tkachuk getting boxed out, hemmed in his own zone, unable to manufacture a single point against the Hurricanes' top pairs.

-

Whether that ugly playoff sample changes anything in the room is a separate question. Friedman's reporting suggests it hasn't. Yet.

Previously

Cale Makar's vicious headshot is putting his next game in serious doubt

The wild scene in Montreal after beating Tampa in Game 7 is going viral

The promise Bowman made McDavid and Draisaitl is about to come due

POLL

1 HOUR AGO   |   25 ANSWERS Senators trading Brady Tkachuk? Friedman outlines the only scenario Should the Senators trade Brady Tkachuk this summer if a contender makes a strong offer?

▢    Yes

▢    No

MUST READ

25 minutes ago  |  By Skyler Walker Cameras capture the bench moment that has Avalanche fans worried about Cale Makar

54 minutes ago  |  By Skyler Walker Cale Makar scare erupts after Marcus Foligno sends him crashing into the glass

4 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet Cale Makar's vicious headshot is putting his next game in serious doubt

5 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet The wild scene in Montreal after beating Tampa in Game 7 is going viral

5 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet The promise Bowman made McDavid and Draisaitl is about to come due

7 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet The Avalanche's worst nightmare just unfolded

8 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet The message Montembeault sent Dobes has people talking

9 hours ago  |  By Jonathan Ouimet Kucherov's questionable Game 7 call says everything about Tampa's panic

MORE STORIES