Martin St-Louis, the Canadiens head coach, is facing fresh heat after Réjean Tremblay reported that some voices around the game are questioning his playoff handling.
That's the part that catches attention, because the doubt isn't tied to the regular season.
It's tied to what happened once the games tightened and every bench move started carrying more weight.
In a recent column, Tremblay said those concerns came out of a frank discussion with important hockey people.
He presented the comments as opinions from anonymous sources, not as confirmed internal decisions.
That distinction matters.
This is not a report that the Canadiens are moving on from Martin St-Louis. It's a report that his grip on the long-term picture is being debated in some circles.
The regular season progress still gets recognized.
That much is clear. The Canadiens took steps forward, and that growth has not been dismissed by the people Tremblay referenced.
But the playoff conversation shifts the tone.
Once the first-round series against Tampa Bay became the focus, the praise gave way to a much harder review of how St-Louis handled the bench.
According to Tremblay's sources, Montreal was fortunate to even push that matchup as far as it did. That's where the sharpest line in the piece lands.
“We would replay the seventh game a hundred times, and the Canadiens would lose 99 times,” Tremblay said.
The playoff criticism is about bench control for Martin St-Louis
“We would replay the seventh game a hundred times, and the Canadiens would lose 99 times,” Tremblay wrote.
That quote cuts right to the heart of the issue. The criticism isn't about effort, emotion, or buy-in from the locker room. It's about tactical control when a series starts slipping.
St. Louis is described as rigid and stubborn in the playoffs.
The complaint is that his in-game adjustments didn't come fast enough, especially against a structured opponent that kept squeezing space.
Tremblay's sources also questioned whether St-Louis showed the kind of bench management needed to outmaneuver a coach like Rod Brind'Amour in a tight series.
He even framed that criticism against older-school bench bosses such as Bob Hartley and Michel Therrien, both known for direct game management and quick counters under pressure.
The strongest quote in the piece leaves little room for softness:
“I am far from convinced that he will be the coach when the time comes to win the Cup,” an anonymous source confided.
Now the pressure shifts to next season. Martin St-Louis doesn't just need progress again. He needs to show that when the playoffs return, he can adjust fast enough to quiet this talk.
Should the Canadiens still trust Martin St-Louis behind the bench?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Heartbreaking tragedy out of the hockey world leaves 21-year-old alongside his grandfather dead
