Alexi Medvedev's numbers this week didn't do him any favors, and the questions around his game are getting louder.
The Vancouver Canucks second-round pick allowed seven goals in a game one loss to Seattle after moving to the Victoria Royals from London a week earlier.
That kind of outing raises real questions about his hockey IQ, not just a bad bounce or two.
Several of the goals he allowed on Saturday were the type a goaltender wants back, the sort of mistakes that come from reads rather than raw talent.
Medvedev went into last season in London expected to hold down the starting job, and he lost it over the course of the year.
He got a second chance in the playoffs when London had its back against the wall against the Sault Ste. Marie Greyhounds, and he actually played well in that stretch.
He's talented. He's technically sound. But talent alone hasn't translated into holding a starter's job over a full season yet.
Why this season matters more than any before it
Goaltending prospects often get evaluated on athleticism first, but eventually the save percentage has to match the hype, and that hasn't happened for Medvedev yet.
He's back in the CHL now and expected to be London's starter, and holding that job without losing it again is the real test this year.
College options and American League paths remain available down the road, but neither replaces the need to prove himself as a true No. 1 right now.
Compare his trajectory to other goaltending prospects who came through this same organization. Names like Thatcher Demko and Arturs Silovs generated real buzz by this same age, the kind scouts talk about in hushed, excited tones.
Nobody is talking about Medvedev that way yet, and it's hard to argue he's earned it based on results so far.
He's entering his draft-plus-three season, a critical checkpoint for any prospect trying to stay relevant in an organization's long-term plans.
Vancouver finished dead last in the league standings this past season, and a rebuild that steep needs internal answers wherever it can find them.
If Medvedev stabilizes his game, he could become a real piece of that rebuild down the line. If the inconsistency continues, a promising second-round pick turns into a much harder pick to defend.
Will Alexi Medvedev develop into a legitimate NHL goaltending prospect?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Sergei Bobrovsky breaks his silence on his future with the Toronto Maple Leafs
