The Edmonton Oilers and Pittsburgh Penguins are talking, and Darnell Nurse's name is at the center of it this Wednesday.
According to @TheMugNHL on X, if an Oilers-Penguins deal involving Nurse happens, Ryan Graves would likely be part of the return heading to Edmonton.
-
That is the trade logic on paper. Whether it makes sense in practice is a different question entirely.
Nurse carries a $9,250,000 cap hit. He is 31 years old and finished the regular season with 24 points in 82 games, a -12 rating.
That is the profile of a No. 1 defenseman who is no longer playing like one.
Ryan Graves cleared waivers last season. Is he a real return piece?
Graves played only 22 games for Pittsburgh this season. He cleared waivers and spent time in the AHL, which is the kind of detail that does not disappear once a deal gets done.
The 31-year-old carries a $4,500,000 cap hit through year four of a six-year deal. He went held scoreless in 22 appearances, finishing with a -3 rating.
Edmonton GM Stan Bowman is not moving Nurse just to take on a declining blueliner who could not hold a roster spot in Pittsburgh.
The Penguins finished 41-25-16 with 98 points. They ranked 10th overall.
Nurse's Oilers went 41-30-11 and squeaked in at 93 points, 14th overall.
So both front offices have work to do this off-season. But the question is whether the Oilers are actually getting better at the blue line if Graves is the primary piece coming back.
This reads less like a rebuild move and more like an accounting exercise dressed up as a trade.
Nurse did play six playoff games this past spring, going +4 with no points. The offensive production is gone, but the physicality is still there.
Pittsburgh would absorb a top-pairing salary they probably do not want long-term either.
So what does Bowman actually get out of this? Clarity on Nurse's cap number heading into next year. That is it.
The pressure is on both sides to structure this correctly. A straight swap of Nurse for Graves does not move the needle for Edmonton, and someone in that front office has to know it.
Will the Oilers trade Darnell Nurse this off-season?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Oilers sign goaltender in move that raises new questions
