Matthew Knies has Jim Hiller inheriting a Maple Leafs winger the organization should stop treating like trade bait.
At this point, the smarter read is simple: Toronto should put the Matthew Knies trade noise to bed. He is 23, signed, productive, and built for the kind of hard hockey this team keeps saying it wants.
Knies is not some unfinished project with no proof behind him. He just posted 23 goals and 66 points in 79 games, all career highs, while playing heavy minutes in a season where the Leafs finished 32-36-14 and badly needed players who could handle real top-six work.
That is why the contract matters so much. Toronto locked him in for 6 years at a $7.75 million AAV, and deals like that are supposed to be the foundation of a roster, not the first chip thrown into every rumor cycle.
“Chayka is a big fan of Knies' game, and he should be. The Leafs don't have a player like him in the organization, and not many teams around the league do either. Knies is a 6-foot-3 physical force, who can continue to round out his aggressiveness hounding pucks, his finishing ability around the net, his penalty-killing prowess, and his attention 200-foot details.”
- Jeremy Tingly, The LeafsNation
John Chayka also has no reason to rush into moving him. The Leafs named Chayka general manager in May as part of a larger organizational reset, and every public sign since then has pointed to a club trying to rework its identity, not throw away one of its best young power forwards.
Knies gives Toronto something it does not have much of. At 6-foot-3 and 232 pounds, he can win pucks, stay around the net, and still play with enough touch to keep pace higher in the lineup.
-
The Maple Leafs have reportedly made a major decision on Matthew Knies
This is where Hiller's arrival matters. Toronto hired him because it wanted a different feel behind the bench, and Knies already looks like the sort of winger a coach like Hiller should lean on.
He is not just useful because of points. Knies' best value may be that he can do the dirty work without draining offense from the line. That kind of player gets harder to find every year, especially at his age and contract number. That is an inference from his production, size, and contract.
“Knies' contract was one of Treliving's better moves as Leafs' GM, it may actually turn out to be his best work. Knies is locked up at a very reasonable cap hit, loaded with potential, and about to enter the absolute prime of his career.
The former second-round pick has posted back-to-back ‘career' seasons, and with Matthews hitting the reset button after a season-ending injury, and with McKenna ready to show off his legendary vision and ability to slow down the game with his puck skills, Knies could very easily set another career high in points.”
- Jeremy Tingly, The LeafsNation
The trade chatter also keeps missing the timeline. Auston Matthews has 2 years left on his contract, so Toronto is not in a spot where it should be subtracting ready-now core pieces for abstract futures. That is an inference from the roster situation and the Leafs' win-now posture under new management.
Yes, a unicorn defenseman would force any team to think. But that does not mean Knies should stay attached to every fantasy deal that hits social media.
“Again, Treliving wanted to move Knies, not Chayka, so why have the trade rumours continued? No clue, to be honest. Yes, if Zach Werenski is available, that's a unicorn-type of defenceman, a player that is an absolute gamechanger from the backend, and if the Columbus Blue Jackets' Norris trophy winner was available, and willing to come to Toronto, and even potentially sign a contract extension, moving Knies gets considered. But that's not on the table at all anymore, and neither should be moving Knies.”
- Jeremy Tingly, The LeafsNation
Because once you strip away the noise, the case is pretty clear. Knies is young, cost-controlled, productive, and still climbing. Those are the players contenders keep.
Toronto spent too much of last season looking soft around its stars. Trading Matthew Knies would only reopen that same hole.
The Leafs do not need to keep talking themselves into his value. They already paid for it. Now they should act like a team that knows Matthew Knies is part of the answer, not part of the offer.
Should the Maple Leafs shut down all Matthew Knies trade talk now?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Huge Dylan Larkin trade update changes everything for the Red Wings
